Site icon El Gato News

Artificial turf is worse than real grass

By: Lydia Liu

Sports Editor

Artificial turf has become a popular alternative to natural grass, especially in schools and community sports areas where fields experience heavy use. Its durability and low water requirements make it seem like an ideal solution, particularly in California, where water conservation is an ongoing concern. However, artificial turf comes with environmental and safety concerns that can outweigh these benefits. California schools and communities should phase out artificial turf and replace it with less harmful, more sustainable alternatives.

Artificial turf can be appealing to schools for several practical reasons. Natural grass requires frequent watering, mowing, and upkeep, while sports fields must withstand hours of practices, games, and everyday use. In California, where the need to conserve water is especially important, artificial turf appears to be a simple, cost-effective solution because it reduces water consumption. However, this water conservation benefit must not outweigh the significant environmental detriments associated with artificial turf.

The most compelling argument against synthetic turf is its significant environmental damage. Natural grass is part of an ecosystem, providing habitats for insects, maintaining soil quality and health, and supporting natural water absorption and nutrient cycling. Artificial turf replaces this natural ecosystem with a manufactured plastic surface. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has raised concerns about potential pollution from the plastic components used in synthetic turf systems. As the turf is used, it can shed small plastic fragments that are carried off the field and contribute to microplastic pollution. When the turf eventually reaches the end of its lifespan, it must also be disposed of, creating additional plastic waste. While water conservation is important in California, reducing water use should not come at the cost of creating another source of pollution.

Another artificial turf issue arises from the extreme temperatures it creates. During California summers, synthetic turf can become significantly hotter than natural grass. A 2024 systematic review published in Science of the Total Environment analyzed 23 studies and found that synthetic turf consistently reached higher surface temperatures than natural grass, with some studies reporting differences of more than 30 degrees Celsius (about 54 degrees Fahrenheit). This is especially concerning for students and athletes, as exercising in extreme heat increases their exposure to heat and makes it harder for their bodies to cool down.

Sports fields exist for students and communities to use, but their benefits should not come at the expense of the surrounding environment. Schools should consider the long-term environmental consequences of their field choices, not just the short-term benefits of lower water use and maintenance.

(Sources: International Journal of Biometeorology, LA Times, Science of the Total Environment, U.S. EPA)

Exit mobile version